The Lost Art of Lean Bulking: How To Gain Muscle Without Fat

June 21, 2016 | 188 Comments


lean bulking diet

Updated 08/07/2015: I just updated the article below to include more detailed information on how to structure your calorie surplus while lean bulking plus included more information for women as well..

So lately I’ve been getting a bunch of emails and they look something like this:

  • “Hey Keith, what’s the best way for me to gain muscle without fat. I want to pack on the size but I don’t want my six-pack to disappear.”
  • “Dude I need help gaining muscle but I don’t want to get fat. Is there any way to gain muscle mass without any fat?”
  • “I’m not really looking to lose weight anymore, but how do you build muscle without getting fat?”
  • “Neglected and lonely housewife. Looking for company. Interested?”

So if you’ve ever wondered what the best way to build muscle with minimal fat is, then this is the article for you.

And my best tip for responding to sex messages on the internet? Don’t respond to sex messages on the internet.

Stay safe.

A note to beginners

If you’re a complete beginner who has never weight trained before, then you have no business reading this article.

Read this article instead.

Beginners can get away with eating more calories since they have never been exposed to weight training, thus any extra calories will primarily be used to build muscle.

Whereas on the other hand, intermediate and advanced trainees need to be more careful. They tend store any excess calories as fat since they’ve already gone through the initial “beginners growth spurt.”

Structuring your diet for maximum muscle and minimal fat

Gaining muscle with minimal fat is a relatively simple process.

You simply need to eat more on your training days, and less on your off days.

That’s it, in the simplest explanation possible.

By increasing your caloric intake on training days, you’re ensuring that the excess calories are used to build new muscle tissue.

And by eating less on off days, you’re ensuring that you don’t gain any weight.

Make sense? Cool.

Let’s get into more detail.

Calculating your calories for training days and off days

If you already know your maintenance intake then great, use that.

But if you don’t then here is a crap shoot formula that you can use.

I call it a crap shoot because there are simply too many variables to say any formula is 100% accurate. No matter how complex a formula may seem, in the end, it’s just a formula.

Formula to estimate maintenance intake: 15 kcals x bodyweight in pounds.

Women can start a bit lower and a 14x multiplier.

Like I said, the above formula is a crap shoot but it’s a good starting point.

For example, if you’re a stripper and doing your thing on a pole all night, then you’re going to need more calories than some who’s um…not a stripper.

But if you’re sitting at a cubicle for most of the day, then you’re obviously not going to need that many calories.

Basically the more active you are, the more calories you need.

For lean bulking, here’s what your calorie intake is going to look like:

Training day intake: maintenance intake + approx. 500 calories

Off day intake: maintenance intake + approx. 100 calories 

Why approx. 500 calories  more on training days?

On training days, I want you to eat approximately 500 more calories than your maintenance intake.

I say approximately because it depends on a handful of factors including sex, age, activity levels.

Older guys and women typically need less calories to build muscle. If this is you and you’re only going to the gym and not doing much else, then use a 500 calorie surplus.

But if you’re more active…for example, if you go to college and walk around a lot between classes or have a hard labor job like construction, then you’re probably going to need more than a 500 calorie surplus.

In cases like these, make sure to bump up your calorie surplus anywhere from 700-1000+.

Why approx. 100 calories more on off days? Why not just eat at maintenance levels?

So why do I still want you to eat 100 calories more on off days instead of just staying at maintenance levels?

Because it’s dangerous.

To maximize protein synthesis, you need to be in at least a slight calorie surplus. I have no problem with someone staying at maintenance levels while lean bulking on off days but by doing so you’re being too risky and have a higher chance of being in a deficit than anything else.

This is why you should still aim to be in a slight surplus (i.e. about 100 calories) to reduce any risk.

And no, you won’t get super fat. 100 calories isn’t very much but it’s enough to ensure you’re not in a deficit.

But also remember, if you’re more active on off days, you need to eat more to compensate for whatever extra activity you do.

For example, if you go for a hike on off days, be sure to eat a few extra hundred calories to compensate for the calories burned during the hike.

How should you train?

There is no right or wrong way to train, although most people respond best to hitting each muscle twice per week.

This can easily be done with a 4 day upper/lower body split which has been shown to be incredibly effective with people.

The Titan Series (my intermediate workout series) in Superhero Shredding 2.0 has exactly that.

What’s wrong with traditional bulking?

There are 2 problems with traditional bulking:

1) You get fat as fuck (aka you look like crap)

2) Gaining excess body fat is unhealthy

From a psychological point of view, traditional bulking is 100x easier than losing weight.

You don’t have hunger pangs, you always have energy in the gym, and you can go out to eat stress-free.

This is why people get so excited to bulk. They see it as an excuse to eat whatever they want and rationalize any fat gain with the need to bulk.

Don’t be like most people.

Stay lean and gain muscle.

Patience my friend. Lean bulking takes time. A lot of time.

Remember, the whole point of lean bulking is to gain muscle with minimal fat.

And when you’re not gaining a lot of fat like most people, you’re going to think that you’re not progressing.

If you’re like most intermediate trainers, you shouldn’t expect to gain more than 1 pound of muscle per month.

Sounds pretty shitty, huh?

But what were you expecting?

Everyone has a genetic muscular limit and the more muscle you continue to gain, the slower the gains will come.

And the “1 pound per month” refers to pure 100% lean muscle tissue. If you add 1 pound of muscle, especially if it’s to your arms or shoulders…the differences in your physique are going to be pretty massive.

Bulking foods
These are one pound steaks. Imagine these being added to your physique. Oh yeah…

Conclusion

Basically here’s lean bulking in a nutshell:

  • Traditional bulking for non-beginners is unnecessary, sloppy, and unhealthy.
  • Eat approx. 500 more calories on your training days depending on your sex, gender, and activity levels.
  • Eat approx. 100 more calories on off days depending on your activity levels.
  • Train each muscle group 2x per week with a well-structured program.
  • Don’t expect to gain more than 1 pound of muscle per month (yeah, muscle growth is painfully slow once you past the newbie stages)

Have a question on lean bulking.  Leave your thoughts in the comments below.

188 Comments - Leave Your Thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

  1. Great article.. I have a question – I’ve been macro tracking on a lean bulk now for 5 weeks. I started at 6ft @ 10% BF weighing 175lb. I’ve now gained 2.2lbs in that 5 weeks. Definitely stronger in all areas so I’m happy with that. But have also seen noticeable change in mirror with regards to BF%, clearly not as lean. My question is – Is 2lbs per month too slow for a lean bulk or too fast? All I’m asking for is your opinion, not the answer :o)

    1. Not sure what level of training/muscularity you’re already at, but 2.2 is pretty good. Advanced lifters typically can’t gain more than 1 pound of lean muscle mass per month. I wouldn’t freak over the BF. It’s probably just mostly water.

  2. This strategy sounds very practical, and kind of backs up real world experience I’ve had but couldn’t articulate. I’ve been up and down in my success, but saw the best results when I ate to “keep the pump”. I had a good pump after working out and ate a shitload in order for it to still be there the next morning. What do you make of that idea? And I was also wondering how only eating maintenance on rest days impacts gains and recovery in your experience. Thanks.

    1. The pump is just a bunch of blood, water, and glycogen fueled by high carb intake.

      It’s a double edged sword since it helps you look good but the look is lasts a VERY short time. This is why I like to focus more on heavy lifting which doesn’t rely so much on the pump as opposed to real, raw strength gains.

      You need to change your mindset about the pump and stop seeking short term satisfactions. You will not lose gains if you eat at maintenance.

  3. Hope you can clarify on something. If your cycling on and off the high calorie intake, Wouldn’t that stunt your growth for the next day? Because muscle grows through 2-3 days when your resting so, if you ate maintenance on the “off days” that would mean the muscle won’t produce as quickly overall. Is that correct?
    also if you have sources or research that would be amazing! i love reading those nerdy numbers (p=xyz +-)

    1. No it wouldn’t stunt growth if you are at maintenance levels, it will only stunt growth if you are in a deficit. What i find is anyone who attempts a lean bulk always gains a little fat no matter what, it’s pretty much impossible to gain 100% lean muscle.

      If you’re really worried just eat at a very very very VERY small surplus on rest days. And I mean no more than 200 cals above maintenance just enough to stimulate protein synthesis.

      yes the research is out there…i just need to dig it up as i don’t have the link on hand.

  4. If I follow this program how often should I increase calories? For example an extra 100 calories a month or something like that?

    1. Hi super duper sorry for the late reply.

      I’m in the process of revamping this article to include info for females.

      But yes, girls overall need less calories for everything.

      I recommend finding your maintenance intake which as a baseline, use 14-16x your bodyweight in pounds.

      – On your training days, eat 500 over maintenance
      – On rest days, eat 100 over maintenance ***

      ***the only reason I say eat over 100, is that being in a calorie deficit impairs protein synthesis and you have a higher chance of going slightly under than hitting exactly maintenance so it’s safer to go 100 over.

  5. Question about the maintenance calories on off days. If my maintenance calories for training days is 3000 cals, I would eat 3500 cals on training days. But for off days, since we don’t train, wouldn’t our maintenance be below 3000? Like 3000-(the calories burned by lifting)?

    1. Maintenance calories stay the same throughout the day, so i would do 3500 on training and 3000 on rest. The extra 500 is to help compensate for the cals burned through weight training.

      1. I was kind of confused too. Don’t maintenance calories change day to day? Like if you burn 2700 cals on a day you do nothing (just from normal day to day activities), your maintenance cals would be 2700. If you burn 3000 cals on a day you workout, wouldn’t your maintenance cals be 3000? So on off days where you only do day to day activities, wouldn’t you eat 2700 cals because that is your maintenance, and then on workout days eat 3500 cals which is +500? I am thinking way too far into this lol.

        1. Yes but we’re going for a general average.

          Of course maintenance are never the same every day. Some days your job might be more active than others or you might walk a little more. In those cases, you would bump your cals a bit to compensate for the extra activity.

          The extra 500 on the days you train is meant to compensate for the calories burned during workouts. Make sense?

  6. I am a female teen training for hockey. it consists of 3 days a week weight training and 4 times a week doing bodyweight exercises and cardio…my off days are on saturday (even then I’m usually working as a waitress or doing some fun outdoorsy stuff) I am 5’2″ and 110 pounds. I calculated my cals with the “very active” calculator and it is saying 2’145 cals and my sedentary level is 1’650. I track my macros but I am still struggling to subtract some BF (staying at a little over 20%). So based on what you’re saying … just to clarify.. should i be eating about 2’645 cals and then on saturdays I should be eating 1’650 cals? Sorry if you have already explained this..just not quite getting it lol.

    1. the formula i listed is just an estimate. If you already know what you should be eating then use that.

      If you’re trying to lose weight, then you should be eating in a deficit every day, not trying to use any lean bulking formulas.

  7. Hi,
    I have been lifting for 5 months now, so I would still consider myself a beginner especially since I have been all over the place with my routines although I have been focusing on compound movements. anyway, I have made no progress in terms of muscles even though I incrreased my calories intake a lot. I have actually put on 1.5kg or roughly 3 pounds over the last couple weeks but this coincided with the time at which I started taking creatine for the first time so not sure if the added weight is water, muscle of fat to be honest. also, I haven’t made any progress in strength despite adding crreatine to my diet. is this normal?
    thanks

    1. if you’re not going up in strength, either in terms of reps or bumping up the weight then yes, it is probably water weight.

  8. I see that we have to eat a 500kcals surplus. But given the fact that you train 3days a week, it means 12×500=6000kcals surplus. It means about 2 lbs per month… Am I wrong?

    1. not sure where you got 12 from…

      But you get your maintenance intake (15 * BW in pounds) and on training days, you eat 500 over that maintenance intake.

          1. At least 12 training days per month. So at least 12 days 500kcal calorie surplus. That means at least 6000 kcals calorie surplus a month. If you train 14 days a month, you consume 7000kcals surplus. And it means 2lbs gain. You said that 500kcal is better for an intermediate in training days and maintenance in rest days. Supposing he consumes less than that in order to gain 1lb per month. For example, 250kcal in training days. In this case would he gain less strength and mass?

  9. Hi im amanda, im 18 years old and ive been trying to lose weight at first. I used to weigh 135 & now i weigh 113. All i did was body weight workouts, never did cardio but my friends & family said im too skinny & i see it too. Although i have muscle i still look skinny. & so now i wana gain muscle but still look lean. i wouldnt say im a begginner bcuz i used to weight lift in highschool for sports but idk where to start bcuz its been awhile. And im confused about if i should eat alot of carbs and cals to gain muscle or stay with my diet plan & just work more on weights bcuz i dont wana gain fat back.

    1. you should definitely eat more if you want to pack on muscle. Don’t keep you diet the same. Eat more on your training days. And just a tad bit more on the days you don’t workout.

  10. im 6’7 205 26 years old i started working out not knowing what i was doing with nutrition sets reps progressive overload.(like most newbies) but i got stronger and put to much fat on in the process i did this for about a year and a half. So i started a cut for about 12 weeks and lost about 24 pounds. Lost all the weight got back down to 11% bf . My question is would it be a good idea to start a clean bulk from here? And when referring to the calorie surplus do you take the weekly average of your everyday weigh ins ex. 203.3 + 203.6+ 205+ 206.8+ 204.4+ 203.4+ 203.8 diveded by 7 days? Which came out to 204.32 for about a 1 pound gain overall ?

  11. i wake up every morning use the bathroom and write down my weight before i eat or drink anything. these are my real numbers for week 1 of my program: 203.3 + 203.6+ 205+ 206.8+ 204.4+ 203.4+ 203.8 the average of all 7 of those numbers is 204.32

    my 2nd week was 204.6 205.4 206.4 203.4 205.2 204.2 204.6 which came out to 204.82 which is .5lbs more than the last week correct?

    1. but why would you average the daily numbers? I can’t see the point in that. I would just weigh yourself weekly on the same day and time and use that as your data, not the average.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
330 Shares
Share330
Tweet
Pin
Email
WhatsApp